Apple loses plea for Samsung sales ban

Written by: Samantha Tomaszczyk
Apple loses plea for Samsung sales ban

Apple has lost its request that Samsung devices found to infringe its patents be banned, as a judge says it failed to prove iPhone sales were affected by the breach

Apple’s request for a sales ban on Samsung devices found to infringe its patents has been rejected.

A jury ruled earlier this year that some Samsung products copied Apple’s, but a Californian judge yesterday said this did not mean they should be banned.

District judge Lucy Koh said there was not enough evidence the infringement had damaged Apple’s sales. It did not show any iPhone sales lost to the Galaxy SII and other Samsung smartphones in the case were the cause of patent infringement.

“The phones at issue in this case contain a broad range of features, only a small fraction of which are covered by Apple’s patents,” Koh said.

“Though Apple does have some interest in retaining certain features as exclusive to Apple, it does not follow that entire products must be forever banned from the market because they incorporate, among their myriad features, a few narrow protected functions.”

Samsung’s motion for a new trial was also denied, however.

Leave a Reply

To advertise on this site, call 0203 122 0872

Recent Comments

Maybe they shouldn't have outsourced all their Engineers to Ericsson then! They were warned they were putting the network at risk, did they care? Did they heck, all comes down to the money and th...
EE User As you say, no TING is faultproof - including your comment!...
will vodafone also be splitting from cable and wireless as well in that case?...
Down with vodafone based on their arrogance, cancel your mobile contracts with them until they play fair...
Mobile working is the buzz-word right now and something the government is encouraging. Being able to work on a train will, in turn, help boost productivity and the economy. You could go around in...
That's updated James - missed removing a couple of dashes as this was originally a story for the print edition. Hope you can enjoy your day now....
Dear Pádraig McGarrigle Does your computer have spell checker? every- thing, opportu- nities, op- eration. Seriously?...
if the train companies want to provide it, i have no problem. same as if hotels provide it, i have no problem. I do have a problem with tax payers funding it. Ticket prices are paid to the train ...
You don't think that, given the huge amount of money the government receive from the over-inflated prices, those commuters deserve something back? Most people can access free wifi in stations, su...
why should there be free wifi on trains? and how is it free if my taxes are paying for it. They should advertise taxpayer paid for wifi on trains. how about free wifi in my house instead, why ...

Social Media Feed